(s)os.

I’m not a computer engineer, but I know this much: modern operating systems are more bloated than Rush Limbaugh’s ego after winning a hot-dog eating contest.

 

Operating systems should be transparent; that is, they shouldn’t get in the way of you doing your work.  You shouldn’t notice them.  As far as I’m concerned, an OS should trust me to organize, manage, and store my files where and how I want to and not try to force me into an overly simplistic categories like “my documents,” “my music,” and “my pictures.”  I don’t want to have to use search tools every time I need a file, so I organize things in a consistent, logical way.  I only use the clever search or indexing tools in the one-in-a-thousand case where I can’t find the file I’m looking for, usually because it’s from the distant, distant past, when computers made sense. 

 

Remember the old days when you only updated software once or maybe twice a year?  Now it seems like literally every other time I boot a machine there’s a new patch that needs to be installed.  Have coders gotten more incompetent?  Or has quality control lapsed because they know they can keep fixing things with patches and there’s no pressure to just get it right the first time?  It used to be that software updates were more about feature upgrades with a few bug fixes thrown in.  These days I install a new patch and the changes are invisible; I assume it’s all about plugging holes in security, but who really knows?  Maybe Microsoft is just keeping track of what I buy on Amazon.  (By the way, can you think of any other category of consumer product that ships with as many known defects as software?)

 

And why does it take so long to boot or shut down?  CPUs get faster and faster, and systems come with more and more RAM, but the OS with the double jumbo Swiss-army-knife feature set takes two minutes to boot and longer to shut down.  (And even longer if the machine has been downloading updates the whole time it was on.)  I have an old clunker machine running Windows 2000 with a hard drive that’s scotch-taped to the bottom of the case, and it boots in about ten seconds.  And it pretty much does everything I need.

 

In retrospect, I have to admit that Windows XP with Windows Explorer was pretty good.  You could turn off or ignore most of the annoying features and set it up to use the Windows Classic look to give a reasonably streamlined GUI that was also pretty stable.  I’m seriously considering investing in a copy on ebay and just using that for the rest of my life.  If that’s possible.

 

But Microsoft threw all that out for Vista, because they just have to keep trying to compete with Mac.  In other words, they went for trendy, not transparent.  (Maybe all those PC-guy/Mac-guy commercials hit a nerve.)   All those cool swooshing graphics get old after about five minutes, but I’ll bet it took a lot of lines of code to pull off.  When I want to open or close a window, I just want it to happen quickly; I don’t want to wait for your clever complicated graphics, even if it only takes a second or two.  Get out of my way.

 

“Too clever by half,” as my Mac-addicted boss would say.  Interestingly, nearly all of the managers in my division at work use Macs.  But these guys are from the generation of techies that cut their teeth on Apple II’s and never switched over, not the generation of punk-ass kids that picked their first machine because it was ooooooh! Translucent blue!

 

If the software companies wrote bug-free, usable code, they’d all be out of work.  So they keep force-feeding us new updates and inventing new features that we don’t need and dressing them up with fancy graphics to sucker us into upgrading (or force their new systems on us when we upgrade).

 

I don’t want fancy whooshing graphics.  I don’t want games.  I don’t want the machine to be hijacked while installing updates once a week.  I want the computer to boot fast, shut down fast, to not crash, and to let me remove external media whenever I damn well want to.  I want a decent scientific calculator, a text editor, and a simple file browsing tool with tool panes like Windows Explorer.  I want Internet Explorer to disappear from the face of the earth and never be mentioned again.  I want a simple photo editing program that will let me view jpgs and tiffs, make simple alterations like cropping, rotating by fractions of a degree, and making brightness adjustments, and let me add text and arrows.  I want a simple, intuitive, bullet-proof CD writer that doesn’t store up files to write to a CD at some indeterminate time in the future.  I want a simple media player that plays all main variants of mp3s and wavs.  And that’s pretty much it.

 

I swear, it’s getting worse, not better.  There may be all kinds of behind-the-scenes reasons to update the OS (64-bit processing and all that), but in the process they’ve messed up the front end, and that’s the part I really care about. 

 

But I have to admit, all those PC-guy/Mac-guy commercials are pretty funny.


screeds & diatribes

home